I cant understand the obsession w/ DMW. It looks to me like the topic here is a bit more broad..
Quote:
Originally Posted by sloonan  What is good roleplaying versus bad? |
My 2 on this goes like this:
As a role player : If your role requires you to brief or seek the confidence of a ref on your stunt (before, during or after) it had gone to far (bad roleplaying). Unfortunately for the roleplayers at large, a high percentage of scenario refs I encounter are poorly prepared for role players - and really should be reffing recball somewhere. If the refs would dig into the rules, read and study into the mechanics of scenario reffing, I think I would feel differently, and the scenario games more interesting.
As a role player : If your stunt does not use a rule (or lack there of) as the reason it could or should work, then it is a decent stunt.
If you can look at your stunt, and feel confidentely that it is in "the spirit of the game" and complies w/ both of the above (doesnt need a ref & doesn't reply on a rule) - then its good role playing.