I played at HPP for the first time last weekend and preferred it over Jaegers. The lady working there, Kim, was extremely friendly and struck up a conversation with me. The prices were better than Jaeger's as well.
Granted, I only played airball but it seemed like a good spot.
As you said though, Jaegers is 15-20 minutes from me in Westport whereas HPP is 45-50 minutes.