mcarterbrown.com

mcarterbrown.com (http://www.mcarterbrown.com/forums/)
-   The Dead Zone (http://www.mcarterbrown.com/forums/dead-zone/)
-   -   Barrel length (http://www.mcarterbrown.com/forums/dead-zone/3576-barrel-length.html)

Uranus 09-09-2006 11:13 PM

Barrel length
 
I rember reading an article on barrel lenght, (I think it was from warPig) Claming that after 8'' of barrel the ball slows down. Do you guys rember this?

Painthappy 09-10-2006 01:12 AM

Not slows down.. The idea was that it did not significantly improve on accuracy.

While I don't completely agree with it, there is merit on it...

We are dealing with just paintballs... not perfect... That's where most of the problem comes from.

Personally, I think 12 to 14 is perfect on both accuracy and efficency.

It works like this:

The longer the barrel, you do increase accuracy, but you also loose efficency. The ball leaves the barrel at 300 fps (for argument sake) but in the barrel is drag... So the longer the barrel, the more you need to turn up your fps. You can try this on your own if you wish.

Put on an 18" barrel, and set it for 300 fps. Put on a shorter barrel 8" barrel, and you'll be shooting a lot higher fps.


----

So.. looking at it like that.. if you did it the OTHER way... have a short barrel, say 8".. and you put on an 10" or higher.. then yes, it WILL slow down. Because of the extra barrel length and drag on the ball...


I think there is a fine line between accuracy and efficency... I've been trying to find it. Maybe this winter I'll find the perfect barrel length.

pillage 09-10-2006 06:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Painthappy (Post 29076)
Not slows down.. The idea was that it did not significantly improve on accuracy.

While I don't completely agree with it, there is merit on it...

We are dealing with just paintballs... not perfect... That's where most of the problem comes from.

Personally, I think 12 to 14 is perfect on both accuracy and efficency.

It works like this:

The longer the barrel, you do increase accuracy, but you also loose efficency. The ball leaves the barrel at 300 fps (for argument sake) but in the barrel is drag... So the longer the barrel, the more you need to turn up your fps. You can try this on your own if you wish.

Put on an 18" barrel, and set it for 300 fps. Put on a shorter barrel 8" barrel, and you'll be shooting a lot higher fps.


----

So.. looking at it like that.. if you did it the OTHER way... have a short barrel, say 8".. and you put on an 10" or higher.. then yes, it WILL slow down. Because of the extra barrel length and drag on the ball...


I think there is a fine line between accuracy and efficency... I've been trying to find it. Maybe this winter I'll find the perfect barrel length.

I remember reading that article, I got from it that 8" barrels might be more efficent in terms of gas usage. I tend to agree that a 10 to 14 inch barrel seems to work the best all around. Now if all the paintballs were the same size and perfectly round the variability would be reduced. If someone wanted to see how much barrel length affects gas usage, use a 68 caliber plastic marble to eliminate the varibles caused the odd shapes from paintball to paintball. One would have to use the same style and type barrel in different lengths to eliminate differences in bore size and or venting as well as bore composition. The marble should give consistant shots, but it still might be a moot point as one shouldn`t shoot them at people and paintballs vary too much.

Talfuchre 09-10-2006 08:38 AM

Everything said above is correct. However, the averge paintball barrel is a 2-peice and thus the second portion of the barrel does not touch the paintball (in most 2 peice barrels). For instance, the Freak is .700 at the tip.

What is said above applies only to one peice straight bored barrels.

There is also a point and aim factor. I seem to aim better with a barrel longer than 10 inches. 14 to 15 seems ideal to me. Not too long but I can aim well and also mold airball bunkers with my barrel.

TF

badkarma 09-10-2006 04:35 PM

Was it the article that Glen Palmer wrote?

DCB 09-10-2006 07:52 PM

Read this.
http://www.automags.org/resource/tec...rrel_eff.shtml

http://www.automags.org/resource/tec...boresize.shtml

I saw something about shooting a short barrel (like the 6in Phantom) that if you chronograph it a 280 fps that in actuality the ball is still accelerating after it leaves the barrel.?

Peace

sniper1rfa 09-10-2006 08:03 PM

Actually, i have found that the ball does a significant portion of its acceleration in the tip of a two peice barrel. Try taking a freak insert out and using just the barrel some time. Beside the incessant barrel breaks, it actually isnt super hard to acheive 300 fps.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Talfuchre (Post 29114)
Everything said above is correct. However, the averge paintball barrel is a 2-peice and thus the second portion of the barrel does not touch the paintball (in most 2 peice barrels). For instance, the Freak is .700 at the tip.

What is said above applies only to one peice straight bored barrels.

There is also a point and aim factor. I seem to aim better with a barrel longer than 10 inches. 14 to 15 seems ideal to me. Not too long but I can aim well and also mold airball bunkers with my barrel.

TF


Frontier_Bill 09-10-2006 08:31 PM

Yes, but you are still using some of that 8", it just happens to be at the latter end of the barrel without an insert.

jwigum 09-10-2006 09:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sniper1rfa (Post 29223)
Actually, i have found that the ball does a significant portion of its acceleration in the tip of a two peice barrel. Try taking a freak insert out and using just the barrel some time. Beside the incessant barrel breaks, it actually isnt super hard to acheive 300 fps.

I think a better example would be to compare a super short front like the ones Doc makes, and an eight inch long front. See what the velocity difference is.

Personally, I like the idea of overboring a barrel after about 8-10 inches, and punching a bazillion holes in it. I've found that I'm a lousy first shot, so getting to take one or two more is nice. A barrel with lots of holes in the front helps quiet the shot.

Wycke 09-10-2006 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DCB (Post 29220)
I saw something about shooting a short barrel (like the 6in Phantom) that if you chronograph it a 280 fps that in actuality the ball is still accelerating after it leaves the barrel.?

Peace

I've seen/heard that reported as well, but I don't buy it. The ball is accelerated by the pressure of the propellant (air or CO2) behind it in the barrel. Once it leaves the barrel, the air pressure is dissipated to the surrounding air and the ball begins to decelerate. Depending on the volume of the propellant, there could, theoretically be a final burst of acceleration as it exits the barrel immediately after the ball, though it wouldn't have any significant effect on the overall flight of the ball.

Smart Parts used this phenomenon as basis for their claims that their All American barrels were the most accurate. The second half of the barrel, just like the "front" of their freak barrels, was bored to .700. The spiral porting was purported (no pun intended) to direct or control the escape of this pressure, reducing the turbulence that the ball might experience as it left the tip of the barrel. Further, they claimed that the spiral arrangement of the ports imparted a spin on the ball to improve the accuracy of the shot. They never provided any scientific data to back up any of these claims, but at one point in time everyone and their mother had an AA on the field. Advertising is an extremely powerful tool.

In fact, I believe a few years ago that either Doc, Have Blue, or some other airsmith used a high-speed camera to capture the plume of vapor following a ball out of the tip of an AA barrel and also show that almost no vapor exited from the porting. I don't know if they also debunked the "spin" part of SP claims, though.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO
© MCB Network LLC